A few examples of appraisal values for
REMINGTON MODEL 1858 ARMY REVOLVER

• REMINGTON 1858 NEW MODEL ARMY
  REMINGTON 1858 NEW MODEL ARMY REVOLVER PISTOLRemington new model army revolver, manufacturer's stamp on topside of octagonal barrel. Serial number 115601 stamped under barrel. Top strap was the basis of a modern revolver, fires 6 shots, loaded with powder and ball or paper cartridge. Can pop cylinder out and replace rather quickly to reload. Made towards the end of the Civil War for Union, marked 105601. Bore is strong. Cylinder tight when locks up. Some wear to barrel. Overall: 14 1/2' L Barrel: 8” L
• REMINGTON MODEL 1875
  REMINGTON MODEL 1875 SINGLE-ACTION ARMY REVOLVER. .44 caliber six-shot cylinder 7 1/2'' round barrel nickel-plated finish and walnut grips. Pieced repair to one side of the grips.
• REMINGTON MODEL 1858 ARMY REVOLVERA
  REMINGTON MODEL 1858 ARMY REVOLVERA very nice Remington Model 1858 Army Revolver, in .44 caliber percussion, serial number 25302, dating from about 1861. It has the inspector’s stamp “B” on the trigger guard. The barrel and loading lever have been skillfully shortened to 5 ¼ inches long, with a replacement blade front sight. Dimensions: (as configured) Barrel is 5.25 inches long, and the pistol is 11.75 inches long overall. Processing and shipping within the continental U.S. $25.00 plus 1.5% replacement cost insurance. Condition: Overall good condition, with a tight, crisp action. The gun is dirty overall, with traces of light pitting in a number of places, and a few tiny spots of heavier pitting. The grips have a couple of minor scratches, and there is a tiny chip missing at the toe of the butt. Witherell's strives to provide as much information and photographs as possible but encourages in-person inspection by bidders. Condition: statements are only for general guidance and should not be relied upon as complete statements of fact and do not constitute a representation, warranty or assumption of liability by Witherell's. All lots are sold "AS IS" under terms and conditions.
• REMINGTON 1858 NEW MODEL ARMY
  REMINGTON 1858 NEW MODEL ARMY REVOLVER PISTOLRemington new model army revolver, manufacturer's stamp on topside of octagonal barrel. Serial number 115601 stamped under barrel. Top strap was the basis of a modern revolver, fires 6 shots, loaded with powder and ball or paper cartridge. Can pop cylinder out and replace rather quickly to reload. Made towards the end of the Civil War for Union, marked 105601. Bore is strong. Cylinder tight when locks up. Some wear to barrel. Overall: 14 1/2' L Barrel: 8” L
• REMINGTON MODEL 1858 PERCUSSION
  REMINGTON MODEL 1858 PERCUSSION REVOLVER, 44 CALIBREMINGTON MODEL 1858 PERCUSSION REVOLVER, 44 caliber, 7 3/4" barrel, blued finish, two piece walnut grips, smooth six shot cylinder, loading lever, brass trigger guard marked with a "D", open sights, serial #97512. No FFL or background check required.
• REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY REVOLVER.
  REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY REVOLVER. Transitional model without ''New Model'' mark .44 caliber six-shot cylinder 8'' octagonal barrel checkered walnut grips. S/n 17196. Accompanied by original accessories. According to tradition this revolver was originally carried by William Boston of the 1st Maryland Cavalry who was wounded and captured near Madison Mills Virginia and spent the remainder of his service in prison. Mottled patina with traces of bluing slightly stiff action minor chips to the grips fairly clean bore. Accompanied by NARA paperwork.
• REMINGTON MODEL 1858 ARMY
  REMINGTON MODEL 1858 ARMY REVOLVERUS Model 1858 Remington Army Revolver, Martially Marked. A very nice and well-marked Model 1858 Remington Army Revolver, with clear US Government marks on the grips and other parts. Serial number is 126804. The gun is clean, with sharp corners, and very nice stamps, and the action is crisp. Dimensions: 14.5 inches long overall, with the barrel being 8 inches. Processing and shipping within the continental U.S. $55.00 plus 1.5% replacement cost insurance. Condition: Very good condition overall, with no blue remaining. There is staining and some very light pitting in places, but the gun is clean and tight overall. The grips are nice, with a clear cartouche on the left grip. There is also a dent on the same grip. Witherell's strives to provide as much information and photographs as possible but encourages in-person inspection by bidders. Condition: statements are only for general guidance and should not be relied upon as complete statements of fact and do not constitute a representation, warranty or assumption of liability by Witherell's. All lots are sold "AS IS" under terms and conditions.
• REMINGTON MODEL 1858 ARMY
  REMINGTON MODEL 1858 ARMY REVOLVERThis is a very interesting old Remington Army, which appears to have Martial marks, as well as being a true Cowboy gun. The consignor states that he has had it since it was given to him when he was a child, 60 plus years ago, and that the gun and holster have always been together. The gun is a solid old 1858 Army in .44 caliber, serial number 99209, so made in the early part of the Civil War. It has inspectors’ marks D on the trigger guard and barrel, and additionally the letter A on the barrel. The front sight has been replaced with an old silver dime. The grips have been carved with “BKT” on one side, and an arrow head and the letters “LM” on the other. The holster is an old “slim Jim” style, with flowers and feather stamped on it. The cylinder area has been cut out to allow for the size of the cylinder, as it was clearly made for a smaller pistol. It has clearly been on this pistol for a long time. Dimensions: 14.5 inches long overall, with the barrel being 8 inches long. Processing and shipping within the continental U.S. $55.00 plus 1.5% replacement cost insurance. Condition: The pistol is solid, and the action still works, although the main sprong is very weak. There is extensive heavy pitting near the breech, and on the cylinder. The loading lever catch is weak. The grips, other than the carving, are solid and nice. The holster has some stitching gone, but is still flexible, and holds the pistol well. The belt loop is intact. Witherell's strives to provide as much information and photographs as possible but encourages in-person inspection by bidders. Condition: statements are only for general guidance and should not be relied upon as complete statements of fact and do not constitute a representation, warranty or assumption of liability by Witherell's. All lots are sold "AS IS" under terms and conditions.
• Remington New Model 1858 Percussion
  Remington New Model 1858 Percussion Army Revolver .44 caliber 7.5'' barrel S/N 97927. Condition: All metal is sharp and crisp smooth with very minute pitting and only a light brown patina. Grips are replaced. A couple of replaced screws.
• REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY REVOLVER.
  REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY REVOLVER. .44 caliber six-shot cylinder 8'' octagonal barrel walnut grips. S/n 72148. Retains 40-50% of bluing marks worn somewhat action smooth bore with light oxidation.
• REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY REVOLVER.
  REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY REVOLVER. .44 caliber six-shot cylinder 8'' octagonal barrel checkered walnut grips. S/n 92064. Reblued with later engraving checkering may also be later smooth action clear marks. Very clean with heavy rifling. Cylinder is very tight. No appreciable dings or scratches. Single action revolver.
• REPRODUCTION OF THE REMINGTON
  REPRODUCTION OF THE REMINGTON 1858 NEW MODEL ARMYREPRODUCTION OF THE REMINGTON 1858 NEW MODEL ARMY PERCUSSION REVOLVER BY NAVY ARMS, 44 caliber, 8" octagonal barrel, smooth walnut grips, blued finish, brass trigger guard, six shot smooth cylinder, loading lever, fixed sights serial #3828, manufactured by Pietta. No FFL or background check required.
• Remington New Model 1858 Army
  Remington New Model 1858 Army Percussion Revolver .44 cal. 7.5'' barrel S/N 45958. Brass triggerguard; walnut grips with cartouche. Condition: Revolver has a nice balanced even patina. Grips have a chip out on the left grip with a readable cartouche. Mechanically fine.
• REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY CONVERSION
  REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY CONVERSION REVOLVER. .36 caliber six-shot cylinder 8'' octagonal barrel marked with ''NJ '' brass trigger guard walnut grips with slot for detachable stock. S/n 71504. Brown patina original finish on grips some dings and dents.
• REMINGTON MODEL 1858 ARMY
  REMINGTON MODEL 1858 ARMY REVOLVERUS Remington New Model Army Percussion Revolver, Martially Marked. A well- marked Remington New Model Army Revolver, in .44 caliber, serial number 44123, with a crisp cartouche on the walnut grip, and martial stamps visible on the brass and steel parts. Dimensions: 14.5 inches long overall, with the barrel being 8 inches long. Processing and shipping in the continental U.S. $55.00 plus 1.5% replacement cost insurance. Condition: The steel has been over cleaned. There are patches of heavy pitting on the loading lever, and on one spot on the cylinder. There are patches of lighter pitting in small spots on the barrel and the frame. The gun has an incredibly crisp and tight action, and the grips retain their original finish and nice cartouche, although there are minor slivers missing on the right grip. The front sight may be a replacement. Despite the patches of pitting, the majority of the steel is clean. Witherell's strives to provide as much information and photographs as possible but encourages in-person inspection by bidders. Condition: statements are only for general guidance and should not be relied upon as complete statements of fact and do not constitute a representation, warranty or assumption of liability by Witherell's. All lots are sold "AS IS" under terms and conditions.
• New Model 1858 Remington Army
  New Model 1858 Remington Army Percussion Revolver .44 cal. 8'' octagonal barrel S/N 93509. Blued finish walnut grips with cartouche. Condition: All markings are sharp and crisp. Barrel and frame retain 80% of the original blue finish with some thinning on top of barrel. Cylinder retains 90% of the original blue finish with drag mark through the cylinder stops and some very tiny browns spots rising through the blue finish. Grips are excellent showing a mint cartouche and very nice opened-grain wood. brass terigger guard with nice untouched patina.
• REMINGTON PERCUSSION REVOLVER. New
  REMINGTON PERCUSSION REVOLVER. New Model Army .44 caliber 8'' octagonal barrel walnut grips. S/n. 19978. 70% blueing name and patent dates on barrel top cartouche on left grip. Brass trigger guard. Cylinder does not rotate when hammer is cocked.
• REMINGTON MODEL 1861 ARMY REVOLVERA
  REMINGTON MODEL 1861 ARMY REVOLVERA Remington Model 1861 Army revolver. 44 caliber, percussion, 6-shot cylinder. Stamped "Patented Dec. 17, 1861, Manufactured by Remington's Ilion, NY" on the octagonal barrel, "AA" on the cylinder, and "S" inspection mark on the brass trigger, with loading lever. Serial #10866. Walnut grips. Some areas of minor wear. Barrel 8" long, 14" long overall. ESTIMATE $1,000-1,500 Condition: Some areas of minor wear.
• RARE REMINGTON MODEL 1890 SINGLE
  RARE REMINGTON MODEL 1890 SINGLE ACTION ARMY REVOLVER. .44 CFW six-shot cylinder 5 1/2'' round barrel blued finish hard rubber grips. S/n 1041. Appears to retain 50% or more of its original bluing with gray patina in the loss areas a few minor spots of pitting (on the frame flat and on the cylinder) a few minor scratches (top of frame) grips with minor wear and two glued chips on the underside marks are crisp action is smooth. Numbers 77 and 1041 on the left side of the butt under the grip.
• REMINGTON 1858 BALL AND CAP
  REMINGTON 1858 BALL AND CAP REVOLVER AND HOLSTER WITH BELT. Serial # 9297. Belt has a brass Eagle belt buckle.
• STARR ARMS MODEL 1858 ARMY
  STARR ARMS MODEL 1858 ARMY REVOLVER. .44 caliber double-action 6-shot cylinder 6'' round barrel blued finish walnut grips with cartouch. S/n 7821. Retains about half of its original blueing original finish on the grips.
• RARE REMINGTON MODEL 1890 SINGLE
  RARE REMINGTON MODEL 1890 SINGLE ACTION ARMY REVOLVER. .44 CFW six-shot cylinder 5 1/2'' round barrel blued finish hard rubber grips. S/n 670. Action smooth retains 40-50% original bluing minor damage to the underside of the grips marks somewhat worn clean bore a few minor surface scratches.
• REMINGTON NEW-MODEL ARMY .44
  REMINGTON NEW-MODEL ARMY .44 CALIBER PERCUSSION REVOLVER 1864 war-date serial number 65346 on left side of frame at the butt, six-shot cylinder, 8 in. octagonal barrel with screw front sight, the top flat stamped PATENT(ED SEPT. 14, 1858/E) / E. REMINGTON & SONS, ILION NEW YORK. U.S.A. / NEW-MODEL; plain cylinder, brass trigger guard, two-piece walnut grips. Comes with modern pistol bag.
• Remington New Mdl. Army revolver, 8
  Remington New Mdl. Army revolver, 8 in. barrel, serial number 80807, with correct leather holster; no permit required. 50 percent original color, some pitting and dents, original grips with small chips and separations, holster with several tears and scuffs. Collection of the Late Ruth Scott, Charlotte, North Carolina.
• Remington New Model 1858 Percussion
  Remington New Model 1858 Percussion Revolver .44 cal. 7.5'' octagonal barrel S/N 15324. Brass triggerguard; walnut grips. Condition: All metal is nice and sharp with crisp markings and sub-inspectors' initials. Grips have an old refinish with some nicks and dings.
• Remington New Model 1858 Percussion
  Remington New Model 1858 Percussion Revolver .44 cal. 8'' octagonal barrel S/N 108358. Two-piece walnut grips. Condition: All metal is grey-to-brown mixing with some brown patina and pitting. Grips have a nice dried look with open grain.
• Remington New Model 1858 Percussion
  Remington New Model 1858 Percussion Revolver .44 cal. 7.5'' octagonal S/N 22721. Walnut grips. Condition: All metal is sharp and crisp with the barrel having a very old refinish possibly during the period of use. Frame and cylinder are very sharp and crisp bluish-grey look with some light pitting mixing in. Grips are good with an opened-grained look. A small chip out of the left grip. All sub-inspectors' initials are nice and sharp.
• New Model 1858 Remington Army
  New Model 1858 Remington Army Percussion Revolver .44 cal. 8" octagonal barrel S/N 83444. Blued finish with walnut grips. Condition: All metal has been reblued and retains all of that finish.?Grips are modern replacements.
• Remington: 1863, new model army
  Remington: 1863, new model army revolver, .44 cal, 8" bbl, original percussion C.W. issued revolver and so inspected, G.W.O., chip right grip, serial # 33072, early produc pre "new model" mkgs. Estimate $1,200-1,500
• REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY REVOLVER
  REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY REVOLVER United StatesC. 1864.44 caliber, serial number 106846, walnut grips with a crisp cartouche, blued finish, marked "W" on the left side of the frame near the hammer screw, marked on the barrel near the frame "D", marked on the left side of the frame near the cylinder "P", the cylinder is marked with a "P" and a "W", and marked on the top flat of the barrel "PATENTED SEPT. 14 1858/E. REMINGTON & SONS ILLION NEW YORK. U.S.A./NEW-MODEL".
• REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY .44 SA
  REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY .44 SA REVOLVER Remington New Model Army .44 caliber single action revolver. Smooth walnut grips with steel frame, barrel and cylinder. Brass trigger guard. 8" barrel length, 14" overall. Serial number 23900.
• EMF Blackpowder Reproduction
  EMF Blackpowder Reproduction Remington 1858 New Model Army Revolver .44 cal. 8'' barrel S/N R395507. Blue barrel case colored frame brass triggerguard checkered walnut grips; sold through Cabela's mfg. by F. Llipietta in Italy. Condition: New unfired in the original box.
• REMINGTON MODEL 1861 ARMY
  REMINGTON MODEL 1861 ARMY REVOLVER44 caliber, 8 in. octagonal barrel with indiscernible makers stamp on top, serial number 15072 and "7" stamp under barrel and on left grip frame, brass cone front sight, six shot round cylinder with "H" stamp, brass trigger guard with partial "S" stamp, partial "A" stamp to left side of barrel, "S" stamps to right side of frame and barrel, "R" stamp to front underside of barrel, walnut grips, 13-3/4 in. overall Provenance: Private West Virginia Collection Condition: heavy oxidation and pitting to areas of the metal components, handling wear to wooden grips including chips and dings, appears to function mechanically
• Remington New Model 1858 Percussion
  Remington New Model 1858 Percussion Revolver .44 cal. 8'' round barrel S/N 43105. Barrel address: E. Remington & Sons Ilion New York. Blued finish with walnut grips. This may have come out of the Remington collection years ago. Condition: Barrel retains 70% of the bright blue finish with the end of barrel turning plum. Frame retains 92% of the original blue finish with the wear to the high edges. Cylinder retains 90% of the original blue finish and line through the cylinder stops. Grips are excellent.
• CASED REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY
  CASED REMINGTON NEW MODEL ARMY REVOLVERCased Remington New Model Army Revolver, .44 caliber, octagonal 8" barrel marked at the top on three lines "Patent Sept 14, 1858, E. Remington & Sons, Ilion, New York, U.S.A., New Model", marked at the underside with serial number and "9" or "6" in forward of loading lever stud, marked at the right next to frame "W", six round cylinder with "P" inspection mark at back end, letter "H" at left hammer shoulder, letter "L" in front of the trigger guard, wood grips with inspection stamp at left side, matched serial number on frame below left grip. metal with about 20% of bluing, scratches and rubs, wood good, bright bore with good rifling, action good, the oak case with copper powder flask, later bullet mold, several lead ball and conical bullets, tin with Winchester Gold Mark caps, SN 66816, box for shipping: 2.25"h, 15"w, 6.75"d, 6.05lbs
• REMINGTON MODEL 1858 PERCUSSION
  REMINGTON MODEL 1858 PERCUSSION PARTS REVOLVER, 44REMINGTON MODEL 1858 PERCUSSION PARTS REVOLVER, 44 caliber, 8" barrel, blued finish, two piece walnut grips, smooth six shot cylinder, loading lever, brass trigger guard marked with a "U" and "B", open sights, serial #6124. No FFL or background check required.